|Namesake||A traditional breakfast dish of India and Pakistan.|
|Tribe Type||Starting Tribe|
|Rival Tribe(s)|| ██ Copan|
|Tribe Status||Merged with Copan & Tolupan on Day 27|
|Lowest Placing Member||Luke Spiers (23/24)|
Paya is one of the four starting tribes in Survivor: All-Stars. Their tribe color is red.
- Alex Perry - From Survivor: Uruguay, where he placed 6th.
- Connor Finton - From Survivor: Persia, where he placed 5th.
- Jhet Blue - From Survivor: Ghana, playing as Selina Gaudenzi, where he placed 8th.
- Luke Spiers - From Survivor: Appalachia, where he placed 7th.
- Matthew Fennessy - From Survivor: Poland, where he placed 6th.
- Nicolas Allen - From Survivor: Cambodia, playing as Philip Smelts, where he placed 8th.
- Ash Crimson - From Survivor: Cambodia, playing as Reed Aconitum, where she placed 7th.
- Charlotte Dee - The winner of Survivor: Cambodia, where she played as Seth Snow.
- Jhet Blue
- Noah Mason - The winner of Survivor: Persia.
- Alex Perry
- Szymon Sucharski - From Survivor: Appalachia, where he placed 5th.
- Ash Crimson
- Charlotte Dee
- Connor Finton
- Jhet Blue
- Noah Mason
- Szymon Sucharski
- Tadeo Ramirez - The runner-up of Survivor: Appalachia.
- Paya is the only tribe to have none of its members mutiny tribes.
- Paya also had the most members out of the two tribes in All-Stars after the mutiny, with seven.